The Pakistani automobile market offers several budget-friendly sedans, but two models stand out for entry-level buyers—Changan Alsvin vs Proton Saga. Both cars are designed to offer practicality, fuel efficiency, and affordability. However, each vehicle brings unique strengths in performance, features, design, and overall value.
In this detailed comparison, we analyze the Changan Alsvin vs Proton Saga Sedan in terms of engine specs, dimensions, features, fuel economy, pricing, and ownership experience.
Engine Performance & Transmission
When comparing Changan Alsvin vs Proton Saga in terms of performance, Alsvin comes with more powerful engine options. The Alsvin offers a 1.37L engine producing 99 hp and a 1.5L variant delivering 105 hp. In contrast, the Proton Saga features a 1.3L DOHC VVT engine generating 95 hp and 120 Nm of torque.
Changan Alsvin provides a 5-speed manual and a 5-speed Dual Clutch Transmission (DCT) for smoother gear shifts, while Proton Saga comes with a 5-speed manual and a 4-speed automatic gearbox.
Verdict: Alsvin leads in engine power and advanced transmission, providing a refined driving experience.
Exterior Design & Dimensions
The Changan Alsvin has a larger and sportier appearance compared to the Proton Saga. It features a bold front grille, projector headlights with electric adjustment, and LED Daytime Running Lights (DRLs) as standard. Proton Saga, on the other hand, has a simple and compact design with halogen headlights and lacks DRLs in its base variants.
READ MORE: Suzuki Alto vs Cultus vs Daihatsu Mira Comparison in Pakistan 2025
| Specification | Changan Alsvin | Proton Saga |
|---|---|---|
| Length | 4,390 mm | 4,331 mm |
| Width | 1,725 mm | 1,689 mm |
| Height | 1,490 mm | 1,491 mm |
| Wheelbase | 2,535 mm | 2,465 mm |
| Wheels | 15-inch Alloy | 14-inch Steel/Alloy |
Verdict: Alsvin stands out with a modern exterior design and larger dimensions, making it visually appealing and spacious
Interior Comfort & Features
Inside the cabin, Changan Alsvin offers faux-leather seats, a 7-inch floating touchscreen infotainment system, steering-mounted controls, cruise control (Lumiere variant), and a Tire Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS). The Proton Saga comes with a basic fabric interior, a simple audio system with Bluetooth (in higher trims), and lacks steering-mounted controls or cruise control.
Verdict: Alsvin provides a superior interior experience with more comfort and technology features compared to Proton Saga.
Safety Features
Both vehicles offer essential safety equipment like dual front airbags, Anti-lock Braking System (ABS), and Electronic Brakeforce Distribution (EBD). However, Changan Alsvin also includes a rear camera (in more variants) and features like brake assist and TPMS in the Lumiere trim, giving it a slight edge over the Proton Saga.
Verdict: Alsvin offers more comprehensive safety features.
Fuel Efficiency Comparison
Fuel economy is crucial in this segment. The Changan Alsvin delivers around 12–13 km/l in city driving and 15–16 km/l on highways. The Proton Saga offers similar city mileage but may achieve up to 16–17 km/l on highways, thanks to its lighter engine.
Verdict: Both cars provide decent fuel economy, but Saga could offer slightly better mileage on longer routes.
Price & Variants (Pakistan 2025)
| Variant | Changan Alsvin | Proton Saga |
|---|---|---|
| Base Manual | PKR 2,199,000 | PKR 1,975,000 |
| Automatic Mid Variant | PKR 2,399,000 | PKR 2,225,000 |
| Top Variant | PKR 2,549,000 (Lumiere DCT) | PKR 2,425,000 (Ace AT) |
Verdict: Proton Saga is the more affordable option, making it suitable for budget-conscious buyers. However, Alsvin justifies its higher price with more premium features and modern aesthetics.
Ownership Experience & Resale
- Proton Saga has better parts availability, lower maintenance costs, and holds stronger resale value in the market.
- Changan Alsvin, while offering more luxury, faces limited parts availability and slightly higher maintenance expenses. Resale value is moderate and improving gradually.
READ MORE: Toyota Revo vs Isuzu D-Max Pakistan 2025: Price, Specs & Complete Comparison
Pros & Cons Comparison
| Changan Alsvin | Proton Saga |
|---|---|
| Stylish exterior with LED DRLs | Affordable price |
| Advanced features & technology | Lower maintenance costs |
| Spacious and premium interior | Stronger resale value |
| Higher price than Proton Saga | Lacks modern tech features |
| Limited spare parts availability | Basic interior materials |
Conclusion: Which Sedan Should You Buy?
The choice between Changan Alsvin vs Proton Saga depends on your preferences and budget.
- Choose Changan Alsvin if you want a sedan with modern design, superior features, and a more comfortable ride.
- Choose Proton Saga if you prefer an economical sedan with lower running costs, better resale, and simpler maintenance.
Both vehicles are excellent choices in their segments, but Alsvin targets customers looking for luxury on a budget, while Saga focuses on affordability and practicality.
